Sunday, March 11, 2012

Hear ahead - part 2

The February 27th University of Colorado Artist Series featured András Schiff. It was a full audience for a big named performer but my wife was bored, bored, bored. The program started with Bach's Three Part Inventions which I enjoyed, though mildly. Schiff seemed mechanical and robotic though that sometime is Bach. Schiff next did some Bartok but the Bach muted my enthusiasm for it. What I was waiting for was Beethoven's Diabelli Variations. These 33 variations on a trite little theme are fun to listen to when you can focus on only listening. Schiff's playing was flawless and I felt I could hear each note clearly enough to try to pull out the theme as the variations proceeded. At first it was easy to hear them, at least two to my mind. They snuck in and were weaved in magnificently by Beethoven. I can't say that I recognized them all, my ear isn't sufficiently trained, but the important part relative to this post is that I "got" a lot of them. My mind was remembering and focusing. More later. Schiff is great, regardless of what my wife thinks. As I left Mackey, I teased a friend, complaining "He skipped number 17!" I hope he realized I was joking.

Here is an important point: I'm not a musician -- only a listener. I can read notes, barely. As a kid I played the accordion and again in the 1980s in Germany but that doesn't quite count. I enjoying trying to read scores while playing recordings, but often get lost, particularly with multiple repeats, etc. But I listen to a LOT of classical music, Nightly in bed plugged into earplugs I hear music on Pandora on my Chumby. Typically for an hour or more, I'll just listen and enjoy and think about the music. Pandora "recommends" music based on their musical Genome project. The thinking goes something like this: "if you like this, you'll like that!" A scherzo from a Beethoven quartet, only individual movements are allowed, might lead to another scherzo from a Mozart piano trio. Or a slow movement from a Mahler symphony might be followed by a long slow one from Bruckner. If you seed Pandora with strange composers, e.g. Geirr Tviett or Jolly Braga Santos, you sometimes get interesting music, sometimes not. The point of this diversion is that often I get hear completely unknown music as I'm lying in bed, in the quiet and the dark.

The night after András Schiff's performance, the visiting violinist Andrés Cárdenes performed a wonderfully diverse program with several other faculty. Cárdenes, paired with pianist David Korevaar, opened with a Mozart Violin Sonata, K454. While waiting for it to begin, I'd been thinking about Schiff's Diabelli and the how memory helped me through the variations. K 454 is in my music library, but I hadn't heard it since at least the middle of 2007, so I approached listening to it as if it was new. While listening it suddenly dawned on me that I was anticipating un-played notes. I was sensing notes that were to be played but that hadn't been yet. Mozart's music has always been somewhat predictable to me -- there was this sense that a sequence of notes was always to be followed by just one specific next one. Then the realization him me, halfway through the Mozart, that I was hearing notes ahead of what was being played. The next piece was a Hindemith sonata but here I couldn't "hear ahead" so I wondered it. After the break Cárdenes, this time playing viola, performed a wonderful Quartet by Niccolo Paganini. Rounding out the group was Lina Bahn on violin, Judith Glyde on cello, and Niccolo Spera on guitar. Could I "hear ahead" on this new piece? Yes, it was happening again. I don't mean to say that I was always right, but I sensed that when I was wrong I was only off a little bit and I felt I was right more than I was wrong. The concert ended with two pieces by Debussy and Schedrin and during both I felt I could "hear ahead", perhaps not as clearly as with the Mozart or the Paganini, but I felt it was happening again. Turning on Pandoa later I heard and unfamiliar piece by Dvorak for cello labeled "Klicki". A quick internet search for "Klicki" didn't find anything either but it was unfamiliar to me and I was once again "hearing ahead".

This past Tuesday, the trio of Yumi-Hwang Williams, concertmaster and violinist with the Colorado Symphony Orchestra, Silver Ainomäe, principal cellist with the Colorado Symphony Orchestra and Hsing-ay Hsu, Artistic Director of the CU Pendulum series and pianist, performed the Tchaikovsky Piano Trio in A Minor, Op. 50. The second section of this incorporated 12 variations on a theme. I was unfamiliar with it, so I tested "hearing ahead". which seemed to work well though the fact that there were variations made it much easier. Hsing-ay Hsu started the concert with an intense rendition of Moussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition. The audience really loved it and the later Tchaikovsky. I couldn't agree more.

Before I quit, I want to again complain about classical music broadcast on the radio. I've stopped listening to the radio though I still hear it in the car. These supposedly public-supported "educational" stations play junk posing as art. They broadcast not music performances but just partial performances. Can't they see that the natural next step is to no long broadcast only movements but just "the best parts". If they can broadcast a movement of a symphony, why not just play the "pretty parts". Why wait for the whole last movement of Beethoven's 9th to hear the Ode to Joy, why not just start with that. Skip directly to "O Freunde, niche diese Töne!", why waste time? Mahler's symphony endings are triumphs, so why not just put them all together into one ending of endings? I'm sure the mini-minds of classical music producers could come up with something that would consolidate all great music to one 90 minute CD. Then they could convince "educational" radio to put it into a loop and get rid of all the announcers. Wouldn't that be great?

Tuesday, March 06, 2012

Hear ahead

It's a great time of year for music in Boulder. Concerts and recitals everywhere, with many free and most well attended. I'm happy.

I'm not as active blogging as I used to be. Other projects and activities use up a lot of my time, so it's taken a weekend away with some skiing and partying to free up time for this little submission. It's cold in my condo right now but it will be colder on the mountain tomorrow at 8:30.

I'd like to touch on a few concerts and recognize some good performances and then introduce an thought I had about music, so here goes.

First chronologically, the University of Colorado's (CU) Symphony Orchestra played Rossini's William Tell Overture followed by Tchaikovsky's Fifth Symphony. Our favorite graduate student was concert-mistress -- she lives with us this year and is great. What I remember most was the beautiful cello solo by Andrew Briggs in the opening of William Tell. He's been to our house a few times, so I knew him a bit. He later in February was the winner of the CU Student Concerto Competition along with Cobus du Toit, who plays often with the Boulder Chamber Orchestra, so congratulations to both Andrew and Cobus.

Next CU had "Faculty Tuesdays", a concert featuring outstanding professors as performers. It's weekly and I try to go to most of them. More and more people in Boulder are coming to these, rightfully so. Jeffrey Nytch, director of the Entrepreneurship Center for Music, put together an eclectic program calling on many of the faculty. My favorite was a piece by Graham Fitkin, "Hard Fair" for Soprano Saxophone and Two Pianos. David Korevaar and Carter Pann slammed into this piece on piano and Grant Larson screamed with the Sax. I'd love to hear it again.

It was a very windy Wednesday and the CU Pendulum program was without program notes --they had "blown away" supposedly but understandably. The winds at my house that day, right below the National Center for Atmospheric Research lab, were measure at over 90 miles per hour. CU Pendulum features student compositions and new faculty works and I've enjoyed them in the past, though this one was a little less persuasive. One student composition went on interminably with unintelligibly spoken poetry covering sometimes interesting by mostly boring music. I encourage student compositions, so try, try again. What was interesting was a faculty work by John Drumheller -- its hard to say it's a composition since it was a dynamically computer processed transmission of a live performance by Nicolò Spera on a 10 stringed guitar. Perhaps Drumheller composed the guitar music, but with experimental music like this, one can't be sure.

On Friday night my wife and I went to an interesting performance sponsored by Playground, an off-shoot of the Boulder Symphony Orchestra, a relatively new group in town. The performances, mostly solos and duets, were by contemporary composers like Stockhausen, Reich, Berg and Gorecki. Two performances in particular stood out. Another computer enhanced performance by Ben Cantu on guitar playing "Electric Counterpoint" by Steve Reich. Having heard Drumheller's work earlier, it was a good comparison and very well done. Secondly, with high kudos, was performance of Gorecki's Piano Sonata No 1, Opus 6 performed by Heidi Brende Leathwood. Gorecki is most noted for his 3rd Symphony but has some interesting piano music including at least one Piano Concerto. This sonata was as electrifying as the recording of that concerto and compliments to Ms. Leathwood for tackling it.

The next night the Boulder Philharmonic, under Michael Butterman, gave a full audience a full plate -- Shostokovich, Gulda and Schubert's "Great C Major Symphony". Friedrich Gulda was new to me -- in fact I thought it was Fulda until I realized, after a Wikipedia search, that I had an F for a G, with Fulda a town and US Army base in Germany. Gulda was apparently quite the pianist but an oddball, faking his own death late in life. The piece, Concerto for Cello and Wind Orchestra, was performed by Joshua Roman, a young upcoming performer tied into the TED program. I have to say that it left me puzzled. Roman's cello was miked, though I suppose to guarantee clarity in the cavernous Mackey auditorium. The 5 movement piece centered on a cadenza that went on and on and on -- Roman clearly commands his instrument but this solo riff caused unfamiliarity to spawn boredom. The last two movements were better and more interesting, so the audience sprang up cheering. I guess they liked it more than I did.

While I had intended for this post to cover more, I think I'll stop here and introduce "head-ahead" on the next one.

Thursday, January 26, 2012

Starting a new year

Okay, 2012 has to be better politically than last year. Troglodite republicans have destroyed the evening meal time when I listen to the news. It used to be music but the local station now only plays snatches of tracks so hogwash is better than garbage. What me worry?

January hasn't been bad. A decent Boulder Philharmonic performance of Howard Hanson's "Romantic" Symphony preceeded by the Takac String Quartet featuring Britten's String Quartet No 2 was a good start for the year. I was over-confident in my musical knowledge and bet Gerry Walther that Britten's "Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra" was based on a theme by Frank Bridge, the composer she featured in a small mini-concert. Wrong! She won $5 knowing, as I should have, that it was a Purcell theme, not Bridge. I'm glad I don't bet on the stock market.

A young friend invited me to a BBQ. Not what you think but a Boulder Bassoon Quartet performance. This instrument is a bit of a loner, not exactly a featured instrument or one that you want your kids to aspire to, but a solid and interesting one. This quartet performed an actual bassoon quartet written by Marjan Mozetich, a contemporary Canadian. I've heard other bassoon music by Mozetich and have always enjoyed it. He has a sound -- if you've heard him once you can recognize him again, kind of like some lesser known composer like Hovhaness and Martinu. A true mark of genius?

Two University of Colorado faculty performances were also enjoyable, though my current cold prevented me from completely enjoying them. Paul Erhard performed on two different double bass instruments in an evening of mixed classical and jazz. I have a friend playing double bass who once explained to me that there are several options on the instruments. Most only have 4 strings but some have 5. The principal bassist at the Colorado Music Festival was playing one, though the rest of his colleagues were playing one 4 stringed instruments. Based on first impressions, I though Erhard was switching from 5 to 4, but n0 -- both were 4 stringed. What do I know?

David Korevaar thrilled a large Tuesday night audience with 4 Bach Partitas. He always packs the house. My cold and cough forced me to leave at intermission. Oh, if only I had seen a doctor earlier.

Yesterday was a two-fer: a symposium on the future of the orchestra and Pendulum. Pendulum has student performances of faculty, visiting faculty and student composers. This was no different and, while well received, was problematic. Hsing-Ay Hsu accompanied Patrick Mason in a 20 minute piece by Ben-Amot. The music was fine but following Judeo-Spanish poetry with unpredictable breaks was really, really hard. Pendulum's highlight for me and some friends as Raechel Sherwood's "BOSS" performed by the Tesla Quartet. Though only two movements, it never lost interest and when it ended, I wanted more. Not bad for a young student composer. The Tesla continues to impress me with their playing and confidence on stage. This is their second year at CU and it will be a shamed to see them move on.

The musical entrepreneurial program, run by Jeffrey Nytch, sponsored a discussion on the future of orchestra. The panel included 2 representatives from the Colorado Symphony (I didn't write down their names), Gary Lewis from CU and conductor of the Midland Texas Orchestra, and Kevin Schuck, executive director of the Boulder Philharmonic. The discussion focused on the changing environment for classical orchestra and the challenges they face. I go to concerts at all of them (forget Texas) and I can understand the problems. The CSO is facing declining attendance and funding support and a complex board situation. My wife and I and friends would go the the CSO, but the traffic, parking, dinner and concerts ended with to much frustration. We've pretty much stopped going to Denver. I'm glad that the plans include the CSO coming to us, rather than the other way around. We'd love to hear them closer, perhaps at Mackey.

An interesting observation by one of the panelists struck true to me -- we've lost a generation of music lovers when school music programs were cut in the last decader or two. It's no wonder pop music is so horrid but profitable and covered by attorneys. The younger generation missed out and grasped what they could and it wasn't much.

The symposium was a good first step. I've suggested to Nytch that more follow with possible topics like:

* Orchestral/Union relationships. The musicians need them and I support them, but are they having a negative effect?

* Intellectual property rights and copyright. Are they limiting ourmusic experience? Are lawyers desecrating art?

* The missing generation. How do we get back our children's lost musical experience? Is music in pre-college education dead?

* Programming and familiarity. Are the "classics" limiting the reach to audiences and is some programming overplayed and chasing away audiences?

* Pensions. Can't musicians just die without them?

Okay, enough for tonight. January was pretty good. If only I could shake this cold.


Monday, November 07, 2011

Nirvana Boulder

It's wonderful to live in Boulder and have so much access to classical music. Lots and lots and lots of live classical music. Granted, two performances were live broadcasts of the Metropolitan opera, live classical music is alive and well in Boulder, Colorado. In the past two weeks I've seen 3 operas, one requiem, a Beethoven symphony and chamber music galore, 11 performances in all, and, yes, I'm a glutton when it comes to classical music.

Starting out on a Sunday afternoon, the University of Colorado's School of Music put on a very solid "Marriage of Figaro". Two singers stood out: Wei Wu as Figaro and Meagan Mahlberg as the countess. Each opera performance demonstrates the rising quality of the singers being attracted to Boulder.

Leon Fleischer played Prokofiev's 4th piano concerto with the Irish Chamber Orchestra. This is the first time I've heard that concerto live and never understood that it was for the left hand only. I never realized how many left-hand only piano pieces there were. Wikipedia lists 41, including compositions by Strauss, Hindemith, Martinů, Britten and a raft of others. For reasons known only to pianists, there don't appear to be any written for the right hand. I wonder why?

The university's Pendulum series was up next. A monthly concert of music written by faculty and graduate students, it's always appealed to me. The music is varied, some accessible, some not, but always worth the short trip to the music school. One particular piece, a piano quintet by Steve Sachse, was the best of the lot.

I went from Mozart's "Marriage" on Sunday to the Met's "Don Giovanni" on Saturday. While it's not fair to compare a university performance to the Met, there's something about a live performance that's hard to beat. Musically and vocally the Met is hard to beat. The Met had just been forced to replace the ailing Gary Lehman in their upcoming "Siegfried" with a young Jay Hunter Morris from Paris, Texas. He was interviewed by Rene Fleming at the "Don Giovanni" intermission and had a wonderful observation. When asked if he was wary or star-struck by a role at the Met, particularly one as difficult as that of Siegfried, he replied with something like "When the lights go down and I get into character, I don't know if it's the Met or a high school gym". Great response. The next Saturday he sang his heart out and was a Siegfried to remember.

More Mozart was on the agenda that Saturday. After listening to "Don Giovanni", my wife and I went with friends to a performance of the Boulder Chamber Orchestra's Mozart "Requiem". The Ars Nova Singers and soloists provided the vocals for a packed house. It was a solid performance and got a rousing ovation. Interestingly, after we left the church we saw a flash mob dance to Michael Jackson's "Thriller" on the Pearl Street Mall. From the religiosity of Mozart to strangely dressed dancers and zombies in a short block's walk. Only in Boulder.

Next up was a performance by the Takács String Quartet. Janacek's "Kreutzer" and Ravel's only quartet preceded a Dvorak String Quintet with Paul Erhard on String Bass. I particularly like the quintet. Erhard's instrument looked larger than any I had seen before, probably an illusion.

The next night I attended one of the Tuesday Colorado faculty performances, this time featuring music written by Carter Pann, composition and theory professor. It's hard to select a favorite here. Janet Harriman played a delightful harp piece "Emerald's on Artemis" and Joel Hastings, coming to Boulder from Florida State University, played 8 selections from Pann's "The Piano's 12 Sides ... for Joe Hastings". I had a great view and found it interesting to watch Hasting's facial expressions as he played. Back in high school I had a good friend who went to Julliard for keyboard studies. My friend and Joel both showed the same concentration and intensity and passion. It's a piano thing that I'll never understand. The graduate student quartet studying with the Takács this year, the Tesla Quartet, played Pann's 1st String Quartet. This was my favorite for the evening. I liked the quartet so much that I came back and ordered a recording the next day. I hope this recording is as good as the Tesla's performance though a live performance always wins out.

After attending a graduate student viola recital on Wednesday, we went to the Cantabile Singers performance later that night. The featured work was Ralph Vaughan Williams's "Flos Campi". The violist was Gerry Walther from the Takács String Quartet. This was a first for me, both for the piece and for the soloist stopping shortly into the work with a technical problem on her viola. With the problem fixed, Gerry finished the work flawlessly and got a standing ovation.

Following the endurance test of Wagner's "Siegfried" on Saturday, my wife and I attended a performance of a new group of 13 string musicians, Sphere. Founded this past spring, this time they granted me an earlier wish: another performance of Jeffrey Nytch's "Epilogue". I had heard it performed in September by the Tesla Quartet and now a performance by a small string ensemble. While the composer said he favors the ensemble version, I'm a bit partial to the string quartet version. The Sphere's performance of the young Shostakovitch's "Prelude and Scherzo" was dazzling.

Finally, yesterday afternoon I heard the Clavier Trio (Arkady Fomin, Jesus Castro-Balbi and David Korevaar) perform works by Haydn, Paul Schoenfeld and Brahms. I had convinced myself that I would recognize the Brahms Opus 8 Trio in D Major, but I was very wrong. This was completely new to me and I really responded as they played the scherzo.

Enough for now. Classical music is abundantly available here in Nirvana, a.k.a Boulder, Colorado.


Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Students

The other night I attended the opening concert of the University of Colorado's Symphony Orchestra. Gary Lewis again enthusiastically leads the orchestra and programmed three works: Beethoven's Leonore No 3, Strauss's Don Juan and Brahm's Violin Concerto.

First an observation. It appears that some students are now required to attend a number of concerts as part of their class work. The students click-in and click-out with their cell phones and their 'clickers'. They do this to confirm attendance and convince their professors of their participation. I believe this was started last year and it seems to have a positive effect on students. Or at least I've convinced myself of that based on their reactions.

Gary Lewis's opening for the Beethoven was spot on -- bright and clear and very professional. The students sitting in front of me commented at the end something to the effect "Hey, they are really good! Surprisingly good!"

But what really got me was the young violinist Ross Snyder's Brahms. Snyder, the first violin with the Tesla Quartet, the student quartet studying directly under CU's famous Takács Quartet, was outstanding. Here for all the students was a different representative of CU. Not an athlete, not someone hyped on the sports page, but a quiet skilled musician. Classical music probably does not top most student's preferences, but that night the audience, again mostly students, erupted with genuine enthusiam to Ross's talent and to the orchestra's performance.

I suspect that the kids at CU that heard that performance will remember it for a long time, and perhaps classical music gained some converts.

Resuming in the fall

Restarting after a long absense is always tough. I'm lazy when writing about music, but active in trying to avail myself as much as possible to music.

The summer saw some concerts at the Music Festival. Michael Christie's programming was again not much to my liking, but I attended several concerts. As usual, the orchestra was in top form, but it seemed that something wasn't quite there. The Mahler 6th seemed lackluster and long; Schubert's "Unfinished" should remain incomplete, and the ending Berlioz was mismatched with a jazzy string trio. Enough said.

With the University of Colorado back in session, the school of music has begun to offer the standard fare:faculty performances, student recitals and the school orchestra. The school of music, under dean Dan Scher, continues to improve and the students certainly show it. The Tesla Quartet (Ross Snyder, Michelle Lie, Megan Mason and Kimberly Patterson) played crisp and certain Haydn, (G Major, Op 76 No 1) following the lead of their mentors, the Takács String Quartet. Takács also opened their season with Haydn (D Major No 53 "The Lark"). Clearly the students are learning well from their teachers. Takács also did Benjamin Britten's Quartet No 1 in D Major, the highlight of the evening for me: new and calm and clearly very British -- wish dashes and sprinkles of "Peter Grimes".

The faculty concerts got off with a bang with Elizabeth Farr doing double duty. In early September she performed on harpsichord some Bach's preludes and fugues from from the Well-tempered Clavier. Then nearing the end of September she played on organ Bach's Leipzig Chorale Preludes. As a non-musician, I find her stamina and attention to detail amazing. She writes her own program notes which I find very technical, but she also provides supplementary observations on the individual pieces that helped the listening. Keep it up.

CU celebrated the 10th anniversary of September 11th with a memorial concert that was packed. Gerry Walther, violist with the Takács, performed a very appropriate and somber excerpt from Shostakovich's last work, the Sonata for Viola and Piano. A young Canadian violist lived with us for two years and performed the whole sonata for her degree requirements -- it's a lovely piece with quotations from Beethoven's "Moonlight". For me, the highlight of this concert was a performance by 10 string players of Jeffrey Nytch's "Epilogue". Nytch, who is Director of the Entrepreneurship Center for Music at CU, pointed me to his web site (jeffreynytch.com) where
I was able to access a orchestral version of "Epilogue". I really like this piece and hope others will get a chance to hear it.

I can't forget the Boulder Phil and Michael Butterman. The season opened with Hsing-ay Hsu playing the Bach Keyboard Concerto No 1 in D minor. The program notes omitted that this was a transcription by Busoni, so Hsing-ay worked her magic on the audience hearing slightly different Bach. The Phil's Mahler's First symphony was quite as successful, but Mahler is always good.

Thursday, March 31, 2011

A fun swing of the Pendulum

It was another interesting Pendulum series concert last night at the University of Colorado. This series is a venue for student composers to show their works, along with tried and true works from known composers.

This is the second (or third?) time that I've heard music by Elisabeth Anne Comninellis. Last night's "flight" for 8 performers was quite nice. She explained who the movements were named for, introducing me to someone I'd never hear of, Sir William Cayley. As it turns out, after a few blind alleys on Google, it was Sir GEORGE Cayley she was composing about. Regardless, the music was fine and ended with the performers disappearing ala Haydn's "Farewell" Symphony with the solo trumpet, Greg Simon, serenading the audience. If my memory serves correctly, at an earlier Pendulum series she had string quartet members move to different locations on the stage and exit individually. Must be her thing, I guess.

Hunter Ewan, a very frequent contributing composer for Pendulum, premiered his "Red River Folk Tales", a choral piece set to his own poem about growing up. Ewan has done some nice electronic music before and had an interesting "live" electronic piece done at the CU Black Box Theater with Terry Sawchuck on "processed trumpet". Here in "Tales" Ewan displayed a nice touch for choral composing. The University Choir, under Jeffrey Gemmell, sang and enunciated well, though reading along helped. I enjoyed it and thought it reminded me of the current choral superstar, Eric Whitacre. Perhaps it would have sounded better without the electronics in the background, completely a capella.

A piece by Steve Reich for 4 violins, "Violin Phase", illustrated sound shifting. The ending was amusing with the violinists ending simultaneously, as planned, and then looking at the audience with a strong sense of relief.

The concert ended with Warren Benson's "Passing Bell" with the CU Wind Symphony. It was, to say the least, loud, almost overwhelming the auditorium. I enjoyed it but was amused watching some in the audience hold their ears during the crescendos. I felt sorry for the poor harpist, plucking away for all she was worth and still being completely drowned out by the winds. For some reason I never considered the harp a wind instrument -- live and learn.

Saturday, March 12, 2011

Oh Susannah

Since someone wondered if I was going to Susannah, I'll make some comments.

No, Susannah was not a Stephen Foster retrospective. Don't go expecting to hear "Camptown Races", "Old Black Joe" or "Beautiful Dreamer". This is one of America's most performed operas, written in 1955 by Carlisle Floyd. It was done several years ago at Central City, but this is the first time it was done at the University of Colorado. The setting is the evangelical hills of Tennessee and it's pretty bleak.

My wife and I went last night and we both had similar reactions. I don't like to knock the home team, but I want to be honest about all this. It was less than sterling entertainment. That doesn't mean the singers were bad, they weren't. The music was accessible and pleasant and the staging well done. What was missing was comprehension. I kept asking my wife if she could understand what was just sung and the answer was always no. The orchestra, some 44 musicians, sounded fine but too often covered the singers. Some of the cast, particularly Wei Wu and Emily Martin, had the volume, but the diction in most cases just wasn't clear. I could hear some sung words, but too often they were muffled or insufficiently loud enough. Clearly this was an opera that begs for super-titles. We are used to reading the words for operas sung in other languages, but it seems to me that sung English can often be even more unintelligible than French, Italian or German. Without comprehension the art suffers.

Should Susannah have been done in Macky Auditorium? With over 2000 seats, it was disappointing to see so many empty seats, though I've been told there were more upstairs than I would have guessed. Performing it in the Music Theatre might have been a better choice, though the large orchestra might not have fit in the pit. My gut tells me that this opera would be more accessible with smaller orchestration and a smaller venue.

Was Susannah a good opera for CU? I think not. I suspect the decision of what to perform is a function of the current crop of singers, the budget and the artistic vision of Leigh Holman. Susannah might have been a good opera for CU in concept, but compared to some other recent ones, "Dead Man Walking" comes to mind, it wasn't so hot.